002 - Nitrogen fixation in molybdenum-deficient continuous culture by a strain of Azotobacter vinelandii carrying a deletion of the structural genes for nitrogenase (nifHDK)

Previously, another study (001) suggested the presence of an alternative nitrogenase system in Azotobacter vinelandii, but it was not conclusive. Another, later study confirmed this hypothesis by creating a strain completely lacking the genes encoding the primary, molybdenum-containing nitrogenase (nifHDK genes), so there's no way that strain could be using the primary nitrogenase. But this strain could still fix nitrogen and grow when molybdenum (Mo) was not present in its environment, so clearly it had to have some kind of alternative enzyme.

So in this study, the scientists wanted to figure out if this alternative enzyme had the same characteristics as the Mo-containing one, and if not, how they differed. And one of the best ways to determine the characteristics of metabolic pathways, such as nitrogen fixation, is to use continuous culture!

Continuous culture is a technique for maintaining cells in a constant state so they keep growing indefinitely. At its most basic, what it requires is a container in which the cells grow, with fresh culture medium (liquid containing all the nutrients the cells need) flowing into the container at a constant rate, while liquid and cells inside the container are constantly being removed at the same rate to keep the volume inside the container constant. If done right, the culture of cells will eventually reach a point when their population density, consumption of nutrients, growth rate, and all other metabolic characteristics all remain constant over time. This is called "steady state." By measuring the characteristics of the cells' metabolism at steady state in one condition (for example, with a high concentration of sugar), and then changing the condition (reducing the concentration of sugar) and allowing the cells to reach a new steady state, measuring the new characteristics, and comparing the two, it is possible to determine how the cells' metabolism works.

In this study, the scientists used continuous culture to grow A. vinelandii strain CA11, the one lacking the genes nifHDK for the Mo nitrogenase. They grew it in Mo-free medium, and used several techniques to confirm that it was indeed still fixing nitrogen (for example, depriving it of N₂ gas for a time and observing its lack of growth; or more directly measuring the incorporation of a heavier isotope of nitrogen from ¹⁵N₂ gas).

Then they measured CA11's steady-state characteristics at a number of different dilution rates. Dilution rate is a measure of how quickly new medium is flowing into the culture and old culture volume is being removed, so basically the rate the cells are being diluted. As you might expect, the faster the dilution rate, the more quickly the cells have to grow to maintain their population density; otherwise they would be diluted more and more until none were left. Fortunately, higher dilution rate also means that fresh nutrients are being added more quickly, so growing faster is usually not a problem. But there is a point at which cells just can't grow any faster, called the maximum growth rate, so if the dilution rate is higher than this point, the cells can't keep up, and the population density decreases.

In this study, at different dilution rates, the authors measured the population density in a number of different ways: optical density (how much light passes through a volume of culture; the more densely-packed the cells, the less light passes through, so the higher the optical density); protein content (the amount of protein in a volume of culture; usually correlates with number of cells, but in some conditions cells will have more protein per cell than in other conditions); dry weight (the weight of a volume of culture after all the water is removed; usually correlates well with number of cells, but sometimes fewer larger cells can weigh as much as more smaller cells); nitrogen content (correlates well with protein content, since protein contains nitrogen); and number of colony-forming units (by spreading a known volume of cells onto a nutrient agar plate and counting the number of colonies that grow on the plate, you can get an idea of how many living cells were present in a given volume of culture). They found that with all these measures, there were fewer cells at higher dilution rates, but not much else was noteworthy about the experiment.

In a second experiment, they measured specific activities of nitrogen fixation at the steady states of different dilution rates. Normally, in the wild-type strain, the Mo nitrogenase takes one molecule of N₂, converts it to two molecules of NH₃, and also gives off one molecule of H₂ as a byproduct. There's another enzyme called the uptake hydrogenase that takes the H₂ produced by nitrogenase and oxidizes it for energy, similar to how cells oxidize sugar for energy. This recovers some energy the nitrogenase uses, which would otherwise be wasted. Nitrogenase requires a lot of energy, so it's worthwhile.

So the scientists measured the amount of hydrogen produced by CA11 to see if its alternative nitrogenase produced more or less hydrogen than the Mo-containing version. (They could do this because there was a chemical in the medium that happened to inhibit the uptake hydrogenase, so the hydrogen was released into the headspace of the culture vessel.)

They also measured the nitrogen-fixing activity of the nitrogenase more directly, both by measuring amounts of nitrogen and another way called the acetylene reduction assay. Nitrogenase is not a very picky enzyme; its main substrate is two nitrogens connected by a triple bond, but it will also transform most other molecules that consist of two atoms connected by a triple bond, including carbon monoxide and acetylene (C₂H₂, aka ethyne). So in the acetylene reduction assay, acetylene is added to a container with the enzyme, the enzyme (if present and active) converts it into ethylene (C₂H₄, aka ethene), which can be quantified to measure the enzyme's activity.

They found that as dilution rate increased, nitrogenase activity tended to increase also, producing more of all products (hydrogen, fixed nitrogen, and ethylene). They knew the hydrogen was produced by the nitrogenase because when they added ammonium (which represses nitrogenase activity; the cells aren't going to waste energy fixing nitrogen if there is already fixed nitrogen available), the hydrogen production ceased. They also found that, at mid-range dilution rates, the alternative nitrogenase produced about three H₂ molecules for each ammonia (this ratio decreased at higher and lower dilution rates), which compared to the Mo-containing nitrogenase (1 hydrogen for each ammonia) is less efficient.

The scientists tried adding Mo to see what would happen. They found that, for the wild-type strain that still possessed the Mo-containing nitrogenase, adding Mo made it grow a lot more, but it actually inhibited the growth of CA11.

So it seems that the alternative nitrogenase is less efficient than the Mo-containing one, so the bacteria prefer to use the latter.

Citation: Bishop, P. E., Hawkins, M. E. & Eady, R. R. Nitrogen fixation in molybdenum-deficient continuous culture by a strain of Azotobacter vinelandii carrying a deletion of the structural genes for nitrogenase (nifHDK). Biochem J 238, 437–442 (1986).